Ensiling Compatibilities of Grass and Legume Forages in Northern Guinea Savannah of Nigeria

  • Abubakar, S. A. National Animal Production Research Institute, ABU Zaria.
  • Amodu, J. T. National Animal Production Research Institute, ABU Zaria.
  • Abdurrahaman, S.L. National Animal Production Research Institute, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria.
  • Sani, S. S.
  • Hassan, M.R.
  • Isiyaku, Y.M.
Keywords: Maize, Elephant grass, Mucuna, Lablab, silage


This experiment was conducted over two (2016 and 2017) Cropping Seasons to investigate grass-legume ensiling compatibilities, at National Animal Production Research Institute (NAPRI) Shika. Field grown forages were harvested at 90 days post planting and ensiled for 21 days at a ratio of 70:30 in a 2 x 3 factorial arrangement laid in a Complete Randomized Design to give six treatments; T1: sole Elephant grass (SE), T2: sole maize (SM), T3: maize/lablab (ML), T4: maize/mucuna (MM), T5: Elephant grass/lablab (EL) and T6: Elephant grass/mucuna (EM), replicated three times. Results showed that the pH value of the compounded silages were moderate to fair, ranging from 3.87 for EL mixed silage to 5.99 dark green putrid silage produced by ML mixed silage. The result showed that effect of legumes in mixed grass-legumes silage significantly (P <0.05) affected chemical compositions of the compounded silages. The CP content ranged from 9.0% in SM silage to 15.36% in ML prepared silage. The study shows that silage compounded from maize/lablab produced dark green silage with high crude protein (15.36 %), ash (19.59%), calcium (0.31 %), magnesium (0.33 %) and sodium (2.13 %). Fiber fraction was significantly different (P<0.05) among the compounded silages. Highest ADF (44.50%), NDF (58.90%) and CNLS (39.30%) were recorded in SE silage. However, SM recorded higher HC (17.89%). ADL content was similar across all the treatments. It can also be concluded from this trial that for higher crude protein and minerals composition, silages should be compounded using Maize/Lablab harvested at 90 days post planting. Elephant grass and Mucuna legume produced good silage but cannot replace Maize and Lablab silage in terms of quality.


Download data is not yet available.


Abubakar, S.A. (2012). Evolution of Ensiling Quality of Maiwa Millet Using Four Tropical legumes. MSc Thesis Submitted to the Department of Animal Science, Bayero University Kano pp 36-40.
Abubakar, S.A., Muhammad, I.R., Sani, S.S., Amodu, J.T., Muhammad, R.H. and Akpeswen,T.T. (2015). Evaluation of maiwa millet (Pennisetum gluacum) ensiled with trailing tropical legumes Journal Animal Production Research: 27:184-194 http://journalnapri.gov.ng.
Aganga, A.A., Omphile, U.J., Thema, J. and Batshotlhi, J.C. (2005). Chemical composition of Napier grass silage with Additives. Journal of Biological Sciences 5(4). ISSN 1727-3048.
Ahmed, M.Y., Abdurrahman, S.L. and Muhammed, I.R. (2015). Nutritional quality of pearl millet silage fortified with graded levels of lablab forage proceedings of 40th Annual conference Zaria 2015. Edited by I.A. Adeyinka, M. Kabir S.B., Abdu, G.I. Erakpotobor, M.R. Hassan and A.O. Iyiola – Tunji, held at NAPRI/Ahmadu Bello University Zaria 559-562.
Amodu, J.T., Akpensuen, T.J., Dung, D.D., Tanko, R.J., Musa, A., Abubakar, S.A., Hassan, M.R., Jegede, J.O. and Sani, I. (2020). Evaluation of Maize Accessions for Nutrients Composition, Forage and Silage yields critical Overview. Research and Development in Agricultural Science 3:59-75.
Amodu, J.T., Kallah, M.S., Orifade, O.S. and Omokamye, A.T. (2001). The effect of harvesting at different growth stages on yield and quality of three late maturity pearl millet accessions in Northern Nigeria Tropical Grassland 5: 175-179.
AOAC, (2005). Official Method of Analysis International, 24th Edition. Association of Official Analytical Chemists, 24th edition Washington, DC.USA.pp200-210.
Babayemi, O.J. and Bamikole, M.A. (2006). Effect of Supplementary Value of Tephrosia candida and its mixture with guinea grass on in-vitro fermentation changes as feed for ruminants in Nigeria. Pakistan Journal of Nutrition. 5 (1): 14-18.
Bilal, M. Q. (2009). Effect of molasses and corn of silage additives on the characteristics of Mott dwarf elephant grass silage at different fermentation periods. Pakistan Veterinary Journal. 29(1):19-23.
Goering, H.K.,Waldo,D.R., Tyrell, H.F., Thomson,D.J.(1991).Composition of Formaldehyde and Formic Acid Treated Alfaalfa and Orchard Grass Silages Harvested at Two Maturities and their Effects on Intake and Growth by Holtein Heifers. Journal of Animal Science.69:4634-464
Griffiths, N.W., Micken, F.L. and Kaiser, A.G. (2004).Crops and by-products for silage. In: Kaiser, A.G., Piltz, J., Burns, N.M. and Griffiths, NW (Eds).Top Fodder Successful Silage Production manual. Published by Weyga-Weyga Agricultural Institute. NSW, DPI, Australia. Pp 112-114.
Iyayi, E.A and Eghareu, B.J (1988) Biochemical evaluation of seeds of an underutilize legume (Macuna Utils) Nigeria Journal of animal production (1) 25: 40-45.
Kaiser, A.G and Piltz (2004). Feed testing Assessing silage quality. In: Kaiser A.G. Piltz, J., Burns, H. M. and Griffiths N.W. (eds). Top fodder successful silage production manual published by wagga - wagga Agricultural Institute NSW, Department Primary Industry, Australia. 311-331.
Kallah, M.S., (1990). Forage Resource Nigeria Workshop. In: Range land Pasture Development and Management at Abuja in Nigeria. 17- 22 September 1990 pp. 11-15.
Kung, L., and Shaver, R.D. (2001). Interpretation and use of silage fermentation analysis/reports focus on silage, 3(3). University Of Wisconsin, College of Agriculture and Life Science.
Lehasi, J. K. (2000). Manure Management in the Kenya Highland: Collection, Storage and Utilization to enhance fertilizer quantity and quality. PhD Thesis. Coventry University UK. Pp.45.
Mannetje, L.I. (1999). Tropical grasslands STOAS, Wageningen, Netherlands, 26.
Mc Donald, P., Edward, R.A. and Green halgh J.F.D. (1995). Animal Nutrition 5th edition Longman Scientific and Technical England.
Muhammad, I. R, Abdu, M. I., Iyeghe-Erakpotobor, G.T. and Suleiman, K. A. (2009). Ensiling Quality of Gamba Fortified Tropical Legumes and its Preference to Rabbits. Journal of Applied Sciences, 4 (1): 20-25.
Muhammad, I.R., Mohammed, B., Mustapha, M.Y., Ahmad, Abdurrahman, L.S. (2008). Use of legumes in the improvement of silage quality of Columbus grass (Sorghum almum). Medwell online Research Journal Animal Science 2(4):102 – 112, ISSN 1993-5269.
Murphy, A. M., Colucci, P. E., (1999). A tropical forage solution to poor quality ruminant diets: A review of Lablab purpureus. Livest. Res. Rural Dev., 11 (2): 112.
Nyambati, E.M, Muyekho, F.N., Onginjo, E. and Lusweti, C.M. (2010).Production, Characterization and Nutritional Quality of Napier Grass (Pennisetum purpureum Schum.) cultivars in Western Kenya. African Journal of Plant Science, 4 (12):496-502.
Olusola, O. (2011) Intake and digestibility of elephant grass ensiled with cassava peels by Red Sokoto goats. Tropentag 2011 University of Bonn Conference on International Research on Food Security National Research Management and Rural Development. Held on October 5th 2011).
Ovimaps,(2016). Ovi location map; Ovi Earth Imagery Data. Retrieved on November 4-2019.
Skerman, P.J and Riveros, F., (1990).Tropical Grasses. FAO, Rome.
Thomson,D.J.Wald,P.R., Geering, H.I.L and Tyrrel (1991).Voluntary Intake,Growth Rate and Tissue Retention by Holstein Steens Fed Formalhde and fmic Acid Treated Lucerned orchard grass-silage Journal Animal Science 69:4644-4658.
Trisha-Collins, P. (2010). Is there an alternative to Napier grass? Matching Genetic Resources to meet the Demands of Smallholder farmers. Report of World Food Prize Foundation (2010). Burloug Ruen International Livestock Research Institute Addis Ababa, Ethiopia W 23: pp 4.
Uchide S and Kitamine V. (1987). Silage Making from Tropical Pasture Plants Grown in south western Islands of Japan. Effects of Various Treatments of Ensiling Quality of Rhody Grass and Napier Grass Silages Journal of Japanese Society of Grassland Science 32: 369 – 374.
Van soest, P.J., Robertson, J.B. and Lewis, B.A. (1991). Method for dietary fiber, neutral detergent fiber and non-starch polysaccharides in relation to animal nutrition. Journal of Dairy Science 74: 3583 – 3597.
How to Cite
Abubakar, S. A., Amodu, J. T., Abdurrahaman, S.L., Sani, S. S., Hassan, M.R., & Isiyaku, Y.M. (2022). Ensiling Compatibilities of Grass and Legume Forages in Northern Guinea Savannah of Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Animal Science and Technology (NJAST), 5(2), 64 - 71. Retrieved from https://njast.com.ng/index.php/home/article/view/201